Chris. In fact I do make art and am rather well versed in contemporary art. My main complaint is not the idea behind her photograph but the actualization of it. It's shoddy work compared with Crewdson's. If you put a sheet below the partition in the photograph Zwick's set looks absolutely amateur compared to a Crewdson. Ill give her some cred given the fact that Crewdson teaches at Yale, shows with Gagosian and has the digital restorers from Lord of the rings working for him.

By saying one is better than the other I agree that this can not really be appropriate words to describe the two pieces. The two are just in different leagues.

Sorry for the misspell of your name.

Rodger I agree with you. No one person can corner almost any field in art. But, some people do do it better than others.

Is it just me or is this just a really bad version of a Gregory Crewdson photo?

http://www.kultureflash.net/archive/123/images/art_header.jpg

http://www.archidose.org/Apr03/untitled.jpg