I understand the value of a mandatory tip in the service industry for large parties. The whole anti-stiffing idea. However, mandatory and gratuity seem to be mutually exclusive concepts, since a gratuity is something given voluntarily or beyond obligation (Merriam-Webster). Once you FORCE a group to pay it, in my mind, the gratuity/tip has become a TAX, and I don't think service organizations like restaurants, bars, and pubs have any legal right to charge an internal tax. If you want to charge me a higher fee because there are more than five people buying your goods and services, then I can gladly choose not to trade in your establishment. This forced tipping thing has gotten out of hand, and seems to be a symptom of an overly entitled society in the first place. Regardless of group size, a gratuity/tip should be something I have a reserved right to give as a recognition of quality service. Now if you want to call it a "surcharge", that's another story. Calling the police is just silliness.
Abusive comment hidden.
(Show it anyway.)