Should Seat Belts for Pets be Mandatory?

Alex

Most people know that they either click it or ticket, but should the failure to buckle up your pets lead to a fine as large as $1,000? That's the question facing New Jersey, where a mandatory pet seat belt bill has been proposed:

Assemblywoman L. Grace Spencer, a Newark Democrat who owns a Pomeranian named A.J. along with five cats and a rabbit, has introduced a bill to require motorists to secure dogs and felines with a seatbelt-like harness if they’re not being transported in crates. Violators would get a $25 ticket that might escalate to an animal-cruelty charge with a fine of as much as $1,000 in extreme cases, such as having an unrestrained pet in the bed of a pickup.

Not everyone agrees, however:

Her proposal riles Assemblyman Jay Webber, a Morris Plains Republican who calls the bill “busybody government at its best.” Webber, whose family when he was a child had a Lhasa apso, introduced a measure to clarify that failure to restrain an animal isn’t equivalent to inhumane treatment. He also said New Jersey is grappling with bigger issues, including a budget deficit and a stagnant economy.

Bloomberg has the story: Link

What do you think? Should pet seat belt be mandatory?



Well then, henceforth, Assemblyman Jay Webber can drive to work every day behind a pickup truck with some large, nervous, and unrestrained dog in the back, bouncing from one side of the truck bed to the other, and Jay can wonder if he's about to be made responsible for killing that dog directly, when it loses its balance, or witness the dog's death from hitting the pavement at high speed. Would he begin to think that government has a role in protecting those dogs from the carelessness of their owners, just as children do?

For those of us who love dogs, it's terrifying to watch. I can not drive behind such careless dog owners.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  2 replies
Having had a 100+ lb. dog slam into the back of my seat when I had to hit the brakes, I vote yes. At the time, I'm not sure doggie seatbelts were even available (almost 30 years ago). He was usually a well-behaved dog (former show dog, used to traveling), but he was excitable that day and would not lie down, despite being told to several times. Well, he would lie down, then pop back up.

I will say that, after the incident, if I told him to lie down, he dropped like a stone and stayed down.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
  1 reply
Most dog "seat belts" can only handle very small (<20lbs) dogs. I had a golden retriever jump out of the car, snapping the seat belt...

As long as the dog rides reasonably safe and comfortable - as in the back of a station wagon, behind the seatbelt, with or without a cage - and not slamming around on the bed of a pickup, I don't see a big problem. It's not certain that a seatbelt would be better for the dog than in the back of the car.

But if you want your dog to ride shotgun or in the backseat, then a seatbelt might be in place.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Here in Argentina they are mandatory.

I have a Shetland sheepdog (the Scottish one, a medium sized dog), and he uses a special seatbelt that anchors in the regular buckle of the backseat on one end, and to his harness on the other. I find it extremely useful, as people here are not renowned for their magnificent driving skills or education, when I have to hit the brakes a bit hard. He is comfortable with it, and I can be sure that he will not hit the back of the seat, or worse, suddenly appear over the dashboard, getting hurt.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I worked in a veterinary hospital for 10 years. I've seen first hand the damage that can be done when an unrestrained animal slams into the back of a seat - or into a windshield when the driver hits the brakes. It ain't pretty. And one of our patrons died when her cat went flying into her head during an accident. So yes, restraints should be mandatory.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 13 comments
Email This Post to a Friend
"Should Seat Belts for Pets be Mandatory?"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More