As an Experiment Man Goes without Soap or Shampoo for a Year

Sean Bonner reasoned that human beings have evolved without soap, and therefore it's unnatural to strip away the dirt, oil, and grime of daily life with it. As an experiment, he stopped using soap and shampoo for a year. Although Bonner still showers on a regular basis, he uses just water. He's written about his experience so far, and why he's decided to give up on soap permanently:

As I just mentioned, my skin feels better than ever before. Not that it ever felt bad, really, but it feels awesome now. Still no stink at all, I swear even when I'm really active and sweating I don't notice any B.O., and I used to be über self-conscious about this and would think I was stinking if I walked up a flight of stairs too quickly. So this is a huge improvement for sure. And with the exception of changing climates drastically, even the dandruff is history. My previously wavy and mostly unmanageable hair now seems much more willing to bend to my will, a dream of mine since I first looked in a mirror, brush in hand, then tried and failed to make any sense of that monster. So I approve for sure.

And speaking of hair, that was actually a perfect test. Sometime mid-summer I stopped by a barber and before I'd realized it he'd squirted a glob of shampoo onto my head. It was too late to protest, so I just sat through the scrubbing. For the following 2 weeks my hair was a mess: full of dandruff and totally uncontrollable. Once things balanced back out to the previously established no-soap norms, all was good again.


Link | Bonner's Website | Photo by Flickr user aonecrafts used under Creative Commons license

I've been soapless for years and my skin is great too. Even now in the winter when it's so dry and everyone else is slathering on moisturizer, I find I never need it. I'm just starting to kick the shampoo habit – hasn't been quite a week yet. My scalp's actually driving me crazy right now, but I'm going to stick it out. From what I've read, it should take about 5 weeks before it settles down.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
trust me, people can tell when people dont take showers with soap or shampoo. Remember that greasy kid in class? Yea, he didn't think he has bad hair either.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
No not showering is not the same as not using soap or shampoo. I only use soap if I've been working on the car and get oil or grease on my hands. I stopped using soap when I was a kid, I hated the way it made my skin feel. There are some theories that excessive greasiness is actually a symptom of stripping away the natural oils of the skin via daily washing with soap (more like chemical detergent because hardly anyone uses real soap anymore).

Being stinky is more a symptom of not bathing at all and wearing the same clothes over and over.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Vonskippy - hilarious.

~Before the invention of soap, life spans of humans were drastically shorter.

~Doctors 'scrub' in before surgery for a reason.

~I sure hope that none of you are in the food service industry, handling my food. I also hope you're not my doctor, or pretty much anyone who has any physical contact with me. And I think anyone who lives this way should be tagged and reported openly so that I can avoid using the keyboard at the shared desk at work after you when you've just taken a dump and then rinsed your hands with only water afterward.

I dated a guy who didn't use soap/shampoo because he was a raging hippie, and he smelled terrible half the time. He thought he smelled fine too because he got used to his own smell.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
gee raquel judgemental much?

~before the invention of the atomic bomb, life spans of humans were drastically shorter...cause and effect?

~doctors scrub to remove what is normally benevolent surface bacteria...that can be deadly in a deep wound but are fine and dandy on normal skin

~food service people use plastic gloves for a reason
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Not all food service people use gloves. And not washing with soap is a great way to spread your flu and cold viruses and god knows what else to the entire vicinity.

I went to a CocoRosie show once where this raging hippy girl in the audience clearly had never used soap in her life. She smelled like not-so-fresh. Like rotting tuna. There was a wide swath of space around her because nobody could stand to be near here. Smelly people who don't use soap or shampoo don't know how much they stink because they're used to their own smell and most people are too embarrassed to tell them to their face.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Not to mention that even paleolithic people some 25,000 years ago still made attempts to wash themselves with items other than plain waterin order to be cleaner and smell better- pounded soaproot, fruit extracts, etc. Even tallow and animal fat were being used to make soap back then. Because the cavemen didn't want to smell like gross hippies.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I hope he's only talking about use of soap when showering. It's really unreasonable to think that something "natural" will automatically be good for us: we can't escape an environment that's entirely different than the one our bodies are programmed for.

Humans didn't use to live in dense urban areas, but now that we can't escape them, it should be common sense that we ought to adapt. We need to be on our guard against thousands of viruses and other diseases that surround us. We do this simply by using soap. Viruses won't enter the body through the hands, but touching one's face would allow them to.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I... /love/ being clean. I love the smell of soap and always have. When I was a little kid I'd spend hours luxuriating in a bubble bath, just dreaming my little head off. I spend extra time in the shower /just/ to feel that hot water pour over me, to smell that wonderful soap, and get all those layers of dead skin off me. I absolutely love having clean teeth. The very taste of that sour acid buildup from plaque disgusts me and I can't stand people with bad breath. So there, ya damn scanky old troglodytes.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
If I didn't use shampoo, I'd get dandruff.

Also, I've read that sometimes you get used the smell of your own B.O., so you don't smell it, even if everyone around you can.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I am half I guess. I will use soap to wash my hands and shampoo to wash my hair but I do not use soap for the rest of my body. I wear deodorant and clean cloths and never had a problem skipping the soap.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
There's a big difference between not bathing, and not using shampoo or soap.

When I shampooed, my hair would be dry and unmanageable for a day, then would start to get greasy by day 2 or 3. I had to use a bunch of product, and then strip it away every day with a lot of shampoo.

I stopped using shampoo last year, and started to "wash" it with a little conditioner nearly every day. For the first couple weeks, my hair was greasy (because using shampoo every day stimulates over-production of scalp oils).

Then, after a few weeks, my hair changed. It became soft, manageable, and healthy like never before. My wife (a shampooer) can testify to the state of cleanness. I don't need to use product, because my hair isn't stripped and frizzy any more.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
"In all things, moderation"

Using shampoo *every day* is a bad idea, but a little once or twice a week--or, say, after burning wood outside--make sense to me.

@Oliver -- so why does your wife still use shampoo?
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
re: Gutu's comment: 20% of the world also deals with dysentery (which can be fatal) on a regular basis. Wash your hands with SOAP, people.

Also, skipping the shampoo might be fine and dandy if you have very short hair. Otherwise, you'll be a nasty rancid tuna-smelling hippy previous mentioned. Eww.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I shower every other day (unless i exercised that one "non-shower" day), i don't wash my hair every time i shower, and i don't wear deodarant (i hardly sweat, honestly). However, i will say that as a female, during that time of the month my hair gets excessively oily so i have to wash it, otherwise it gets gross. I don't know how a female could not wash her hair, unless she wants to have a greasy, stringy bird's nest on her head.

Baking soda is a fabulous product for the skin and the teeth.

Like many people said on this comment board, i think the issue with those smelly hippies is that they don't bathe or wash their clothes, period. And that is gross. The worst part is when they think that patchouli will cover up the smell--they just end up smelling like stinky hippie covered in patchouli.

@gutu: i have seen people in india scoop up dirt from the road to brush their teeth. i'm unsure i would go along with that practice
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I'm with you all the way, John. Anyone that thinks that they can tell a person who isn't using soap, is confusing them with a person that Eisn't using water. I stopped using different 'personal' products at differnt times and my life, and now smell better, my skin feels better, my body functions better and I save money. I am now soap, shampoo, deodorant (more on that later, for those who want to judge), and tampon free. Soap does not make a difference, smelling like 'an irish spring' vs smelling like skin. No one knows, and if they do who cares? I do not stink nor am I odorous, which can be as offensive to some as BO. It is also crazy to compare 'the smelly kid in class' to a person who bathes without soap. That smelly kid probably also wore clothes multiple times and was living in unfortunate circcumsstances, real classy to make fun.
I dance, a lot, and I sweated more and smelled terribly after when I used deodorant. Due to the fact that deodorant clogs your pores to stop the sweat so when it comes out it really flows and it also contains chemicals and poisons. It works the same way that a perfume that smells great on your friend, smells terribly on you. Once a body purges itself of the POISONS (you do not need aluminum under your arms, it causes cancer...) it finds a natural balance, that has been in humans since we've existed.
Shampoo and soap operate the same way, they strip away the oils that your body is producing. Your body already knows what it needs. My skin is clearer, softer, closer to the ideal that I'd prefer. And the same goes for my hair. Curly hair especially needs less stripping of oils. I have less dandruff and I started using Cade Oil to combat the lil flakies I had left. Dandruff is now a thing of the past for me.
*Spoiler Alert* Im going to discuss femine issues, if you are immature, please stop reading.
I switched from tampons to disposable cups. Tampons have BLEACH in them. My period is now, lighter with NO cramping. And its because tampons suck your natural 'juices' out, and introduces chemicals that make you cramp and make, your period last longer, so they can sell you more tampons and more products for cramps.
*End Spolier*
Long story short, don't knock if it you don't try it. It may not be for you, maybe you have a fabulous shampoo and who am I to tell you not to use it. But for me, and lots of other people (who you can't smell, stop being an idiot) this saves money, and it goes beyond 'working' into being 'the best thing I've ever done for my body'.
You should also try vegetables, sheeple.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Hmmmm...I have a roommate who drains the hot water heater (40 gal) which is set pretty damn hot, with every shower. Sometimes she showers twice a day. Her hair smells like head all the time. (She lets her chiweeny sleep on her pillow at night.) Regardless of her dog codependency (her dog being relatively non-offensive in odor), her head still smells like hippie-head.

I believe that it is her body's pheromones that are offensive, not her grooming habits. I also believe that if the water bill is $250 dollars a month again one more time, that the bitch bees payin' half of it!!

Oh yeah, and you people who don't use soap ever????..Your effulgence, while generally unnoticeable to yourself, distinguishes you to the rest of the civilized herd, as a Mc.Stinky-Butt.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
mmm very interesting, this post got LOTS of comments. And a lot of very judgmental ones at that. I understand that hygiene is a very sensitive topic but some comments are down right mean and judgmental.

For some people, if you don't work in the food or medical field there is no reason for you to bath so much. It is very damaging to your skin when you are forced to use city water. It is a good idea not to bath but every 2 weeks. But for those of us working in the med and food field sorry sorry get scrubbing every day lol.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
It's weird to me, but whatever. I jut hope you folks who don't use shampoo or soap really don't smell.
My husband's aunt uses soap, uses shampoo and showers every single day, but she doesn't wear deoderant and BOY can you tell.
I know that's not exactly the same, but just another incident of someone being used to their own funk.

I could never go without soap or shampoo. I've had incidents where I couldn't shampoo my hair (but still shower), and you know what happened? I had gross greasy stringy hair.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 31 comments
Email This Post to a Friend
"As an Experiment Man Goes without Soap or Shampoo for a Year"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More