Tipping Properly in Every Food Scenario

Americans know that you are supposed to tip a waiter at a full-service restaurant 15-20% for good service. There is no obligation to tip at all unless the restaurant makes it mandatory, as they sometimes do for large groups. However, in the US, food servers are often paid below the minimum wages as tips are expected to make up the difference. What about outside the full-service restaurant? How much should you tip at bars or buffets or take out windows? This article at mintlife spells those out for you.
Whenever I go through the takeout dance with a host (she retrieves my food, I pay—inevitably with a credit card—and my eyes scan down to that darned gratuity line), I feel anxious. Am I rude if I don’t tip? A sucker if I do? What’s the proper percentage? (Surely not the full 15% to 20%.)

“I’ll leave a couple of dollars, maybe more if it’s a larger order and required more work by the host,” says Heather Chang, a former hostess at a San Diego gourmet pizza restaurant. What constitutes more work? “Things the host would’ve helped put together, like a salad or something that required fancy packaging.” If this turns out to be the case, 10% is plenty.

Link -via the Presurfer

(Image credit: Dave Dugdale)

I get confused about tipping delivery drivers. Often the store charges a delivery charge, like $2.50 or more. Does that go to the driver? I assume so, because if it doesn't then that is sort of ridiculous. And if that is the case, I assume I can tip less because the driver is already getting $2.50, right?
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
There's no way I'm going to let someone tell me how to tip. If the service was good and THEY were waiting on ME (not the other way around), I will tip generously.

My biggest pet peeve is when people believe that the customer is responsible for a wait staff's pay. That's exactly what the owners of the restaurant want you to think. It's actually a rather impressive business model. It works like this: they get the staff to believe that there's "just no way we can pay you any more than $3 an hour." Then they say the waiter's "pay" comes mostly from tips, so if they get a poor tip, it's the customer's fault - completely disregarding the fact that the customer has already paid too much for a meal that didn't cost nearly as much to make or prepare. Not to mention sparking a whole pseudo-philosophical/ethical debate on why a middle-aged woman working at Denny's should get %20.

If you work as wait staff, you'll most likely find issue with this. However, don't kill the messenger. The current system may be working right now, but only well enough to perpetuate whiny-articles like this to go on uninterrupted. It does no good and people will continue to tip what they want, which is usually plenty.

So the next time you are in a Starbucks and the person handing you your decaf glances at the tip jar, then back at you with a raised eyebrow, give them THIS tip: tell your bosses not to charge $2 for a cup of coffee.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I agree with Masada.
If your business model does not include fair pay for all staff, then you should be ashamed of yourself.
The U.S. has a deplorably poor record on employment law, in Europe we think of you as a third-world country when we hear that wait-staff are expected to hustle for tips in order to make their pay.

Tipping demeans both the tipper and the person tipping.

As for the coffee world. You're not a "barista". You serve coffee. Labelling yourself with a silly word doesn't give the job added value.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I agree with Masada but he should have also mentioned that federal law requires the restaurant to ensure that all wait staff make at least minimum wage. The wait staff are paid somewhere around $3/hr by their employer and they are supposed to declare how much they make in tips, which usually pushes them well above the minimum wage. If they do not receive enough money in tips to put them at or above the minimum wage, the employer is responsible to make up the difference, which pretty much never happens.

As for Matt's question: I used to deliver pizza and I can tell you how it was for me. I did NOT get any of the delivery charge. Every cent of the delivery charge went into the owner's pocket. Of course, many people think as you do, that the driver is getting a built in tip and the pizza restaurant owners rarely bother to educate the customer. I am fairly certain that all of the chains are the same way. Don't cheat the driver because you think he is already getting an automatic tip; he ain't.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Its a really strange setup to someone not familiar with it. It was a real pain in the neck when I went to New York. I just wanted to pay the bloody bill without all the negotiations about how much the tip should be.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
When at a restaurant, or bar I always tip according to the level of service I was given. I really can't stand when waiters have the notion that regardless of how shitty they treat you they should get a 20% tip, it's absurd.

I always tip the delivery guys, and living in a place there there are a lot of places where they use bicycles to deliver I tip them well haha.

Baristas I will never be ok with people tipping a baritsa. The way I look at it if you are tipping them you should be tipping your cashier at the department store (you know..the one you have run around for 15 min finding sizes for you, or the shoe salesman that has hussled to bring out 20 pairs of shoes for you), or the tanning salon operator (you know..the one that remembers your name EVERY time, takes care to make sure you have a nice clean towel when you go in, and after has to clean up your sweaty mess? I say thins mostly because in my state basically every one makes min wage (a whopping 8 something an hour) and if they don't I've never heard of any base wage being less than 6 something an hour. I know this is different in other places like the south, so always be aware when you are visiting other states, they all have different ways of doing things!
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I don't think I'd be very welcome in the US (I'm English) - I never normally tip, even to the point where I'll wait for the 10p small change for a taxi ride (I'd actually feel meaner telling him to keep such a small amount).

There's no real tipping culture in the UK, and I've certainly never been anywhere where you'd automatically tip at a bar for drinks - you always pay and wait for your change. Maybe someone might say 'and have one yourself', or 'keep the change', which is then taken out of the payment, but that's really the exception.

I don't understand the assumption that tipping is the norm, but again I suppose that's a cultural thing. But did the person providing the service do something out of the ordinary? Was he/she going beyond their job description when setting down food on your table or driving your taxi? If not, why tip? I would tip (and have done so) for exceptional service, but someone who knocks on the door with a pizza delivery is doing nothing exceptional - I already paid a delivery charge, and the person handing me my food is doing that job.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
The system is weird, even to Americans who are used to it. In a restaurant in New York, I gave the waiter a $100 bill to pay for a $20 lunch for two. He asked if I wanted change. Hell ya, Bud! I thought that was rather presumptuous. I left him $5.

On the other end of the scale, I once wrote in an 18% tip at Cracker Barrel on the credit card slip. The cashier was amazed and called another worker over to drool over it. They told me no one ever tips that much, and the majority of their customers, being elderly travelers, don't tip at all.

But that was back in the days I actually ate out...
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Nick-
It's purely part of the tradition. We understand that certain situations require leaving a tip, therefore we do it. As a long-time tip-reliant worker, we are often seen as independent contractors for the restaurant owner. Especially in places like bars, with floating servers, the management treats it as "you get paid as hard as you work." It's true. If I hang out in the back and fiddle with my blackberry all night, I deserve what I get. However, if I'm working the floor and making sure my customers' glasses are full, I deserve what I get.

Furthermore, tipping well isn't the only way to get better service on a night out. Simply saying your please's and thank you's will go over great too. As we say, "A jerk that tips well is still a jerk."
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
@soubriquet: "Tipping demeans both the tipper and the person tipping."

What nonsense. Tipping is the last remaining example of the honor-system in American society, and it is the only reason you EVER get decent, personalized service in a restaurant.

A restaurant server has opportunities to screw with your food--your food--that a fast-food employee could only dream of. The hope of a decent tip at the end of the night is what keeps him/her from doing that, and ensures that they try to provide you with the best dining experience possible.

I know, this is not always the case. Sometimes you get terrible service from a server. But taking tipping out of the equation isn't going to make that better; if you put servers on a strict hourly wage, with no incentive to treat customers well, what do you think is going to happen?
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
It is a really weird system we have, tipping as a matter of course. In most jobs, if you don't work properly, your boss fixes it (by talking to you, firing you, etc.). It should be the same in the service industry. If you give good service, you keep your job. If you give bad service, you don't keep your job. While you work, you make a decent wage. It works in Europe, why not in North America?
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I am not surprised by how many people have posted that they do not tip, but it is disappointing. You can complain about it all day long, but it is the cultural norm and it is expected that you tip when you go to a bar or restaurant. Not tipping is beyond rude, and it shows a degree of cheapskatery that you should be embarrassed by. After all we are talking about a few dollars, which is nothing to you at that point but adds up to quite a bit for the server/bartender involved.

Keep in mind that the food prices that you see on the menu assume that you will be tipping the staff. For everyone complaining about having to subsidize the waitstaff's pay, you would be doing it either way. If nobody tipped and it was paid by the owner you would see much higher prices for food.

Personally, it's not tipping I believe in it's over-tipping. Partly to make up for the sad, cheap, bitter people who refuse to do so. Mainly because I respect the people serving me and want to show that to them.

It also helps to get better service, especially at a bar. I can guarantee that my drinks come better and faster than those of a bad tipper. Think about that next time you can't get the bartender's attention for your second round.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
@MadMolecule
Tipping is "the last remaining example of the honor system?" Seriously?! You need a corporate chain of Red Lobsters to teach you about honor?!

You can't possibly tell me that the reason for good service at all is because of tips. What if restaurants had a higher set of standards for becoming a waitress? That would eliminate a hell of a lot of people right off the bat. probably the ones who think they're doing the customer a favor by doing their job.

Incidentally, "messing" with someone's food is now a much bigger deal with the advent of more transmittable diseases. Because the staff is in a kitchen or preparation area, they are considered to be in a "privileged position" when handling the food, meaning that if they were to do something to the food they're looking at jail time. Not to mention what I'd do if I found out.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
In the UK there's no way a restaurant could get away with paying its employees less than minimum wage which is currently £5.80 ($9.23) / hour. In the UK it seems to be the norm to pay ~10% if someone does a good job.
I rather object to places that charge a compulsory service charge for singles/couples. Just charge more for the damn meal. I was in a terrible Chinese restaurant in Oxford called the Opium Café where the meal was inedible and the staff rude. When I didn't pay the service charge the waitress threatened to call the cops. I told her to feel free and in the end she extremely bitterly let us leave after paying the full price for the meal but no service charge.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
kangarooz - bear in mind that a few of the commenters - Nick Gisburne for example (myself too) - come from a completely different culture, where tipping purely as a reflex seems wrong - it doesn't remward good service at all - in fact it seems to encourage only the bare minimum, as a tip does not need to be earned. The argument from my point of view is that the salary should be the bare minimum - tipping is for going beyond that, be it being particularly efficient, helpful or whatever.

Seperate note, it might be interesting to see which situations people would consider 'tippable'. I'm from the UK and I would consider tipping:
waiting staff (restaurant)
taxis (though only in a 'keep the change' way)
bar / coffee staff (only if they've really gone beyond the call of duty)
can't think of any else at the moment, though I may have not considered something.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Masada: The "honor system" doesn't mean it's a system designed to teach people about honor. It means that people are expected to do the right thing, but are not forced to.

If someone were selling newspapers and just left a pile of them out in public with a sign saying "Please leave money when you take a newspaper," that would be an example of the honor system.

"You can't possibly tell me that the reason for good service at all is because of tips."

Based on that statement, you can't possibly tell me you've ever been a restaurant server.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
First, America should be following the European model on this one. Having to rely on gratuity for a wage is barely above begging. I guess the only way it'll change on a wide scale is via Congress once the GOP is laid to rest as a party.

Second, you're a cretin if you don't tip in America. I can't imagine how insufferable it must be to be around some of you people. It's clear you treat wait staff as adversaries.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
"As for the coffee world. You're not a "barista". You serve coffee. Labelling yourself with a silly word doesn't give the job added value."

I can't say I agree. I'm not saying that these people are worth $100,000.00 a year, but I will say that they do know a specific trade, and are (generally) good at it. It's a little bit more in depth than throwing some grounds in a filter and letting it drip.

Kinda just sounds like you're being a bit demeaning because you don't see the value in it...but some serious coffee drinkers would beg to differ.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Been working in Las Vegas for a few months. I must say I spend 10-20 dollars a day tipping everyone and I am so sick of this. However I would never tip for take out! Thats ridiculous.. Delivery of course, but no matter how much food its 4 or 5 bucks, which seems fair to me.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Talking about business models does not remedy the situation. Without business reform across the country, servers will still continue to make crap wages. I was a server for some time and believe me, at $2.13 an hour, we do depend heavily on the kindness of our guests. And I do say kindness intentionally, as in many cases you can provide the best service you possibly can in a busy restaurant environment and customers leave 5% and under just because they can. I worked Valentine's day and revieved a 25cent tip on a $100 bill from a smug young man who told me to "keep the change." I worked Easter Sunday and recieved a 5% tip on a $200 bill from a group of big hat-wearing church ladies. Tipping may not be everyone's favorite part of going out to eat, but you know what to expect when you go to a full service restaurant. If you don't have the money, don't eat out. And if you think your single tip doesn't matter, believe me, you're wrong.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
When I was in Korea, you don't tip. I was told that this is common in Asia. It is actually considered rude because good service is supposed to be included as a matter of fact.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
You know what you are getting into when you become a server though so I don't see how I should be obliged to be tipping anyone really. I didn't get tips when I worked in a deli serving customers, why should a server get a 20% tip for something they didn't even have to cook, they just bring it to you.

Getting paid tips to bring food on a plate seems just completely stupid to me.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
People who make all these philosophical objections to tipping are just finding excuses to be cheap assholes.

If you fail to give the person who serves you the expected tip you are tricking them into serving you for free and cheating them, plain and simple. Why should a person get paid less for serving you than for serving someone with class who actually tips? That isn't fair.

If you don't believe in tipping stick to McDonalds and Kwik Trip.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Ok, as a tip receiving employee I find fault with so many of these comments.

The idea that we, as Americans, need to change over to the European system is pure nonsense. I've traveled extensively, and I've received the worst service in European restaurants. Why give better service if they get paid the same? Why work harder if you're paid the same wage? In addition, often times in the European model, restaurant goers are charged a per person addition to the bill. It just isn't a percentage.

Tip what you want. You should know that your server isn't making that much money hourly. In the state of Georgia, our base pay covers the taxes owed on our income. Rarely do I receive a pay check that has money on it. Everything I make hourly is taken by the government. All I walk with at the end of the day is my tip money. So tip what you want, but know that we work our asses off to provide a service.

As for hosts/delivery drivers/to go/fast food/etc... ask them how much they make an hour and/or how much people typically tip. Most often, they'll answer honestly.

Quite frankly, I'm not going to bring someone that 5th diet coke if I know it won't affect my wage at the end of the day.

If you don't want to tip for food, eat at a restaurant that you don't need to tip. If you are morally opposed to tipping, as some comments seem to indicate, then don't go there. But to make a statement against the system by not tipping your server is to demean the work they do for you.

In conclusion, know this: Serving isn't easy. It is physically draining, and mentally demanding. Not to mention the people skills required. So if your server does a good job to make your experience a good one, reward them... with a generous tip.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
@masada

$2 for a cup of coffee is expensive?

In Australia, coffees generally cost between $3.50 and $5 (3.60 - US$5.20)...and they pay the "baristas" at least minimal wage, AND they expect tips, when half of them think the only difference between a latte and a cappuccino is that one has sprinkles.

Australia is expensive!
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I can tell you that when I was delivering pizza I DID get the $3 delivery charge, however that's ALL I got. If we had one delivery in 3 hours I made a whopping $3. Without the tips that job was useless
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
soubriquet wrote: ...in Europe we think of you as a third-world country when we hear that wait-staff are expected to hustle for tips in order to make their pay.

Well, of course, a EUROPEAN would think of us crummy lousy Americans as 3rd world. Of course you would.

Ask me what I, crummy lousy American, think of wait staff in france, for example, who can't crack a smile, can't keep from making faces at me when I ask for a steak that won't bleed to death in my plate or more than 1 ice cube for the room temp coke that is put in front of me but that I'd like to drink COLD and who make me wait forever for a simple meal and then can't even say thank you and have a nice day when I leave?

Go on, ask me.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
@lulu: they prob. had a bad experiance with Americans, i don't have those feelings about france, even tho i dont really like em :P.

On tipping: no way its gonna improve if the tip is mandatory. Im from the Netherlands, and i know we are known to be cheap, we DO tip, but only if you deliver extra service besides slapping it on the table. (remember the drinks, drink on tab for the night, names, good recommendations)
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I work in a resturant. They took out the tip system for 10% service charge. But now i dont get tips or the 10% as the returant just takes all the money for themselves.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Nobody, not even waiters, gets to earn less than minimum wage. If you don't get your tips, your employer is obligated to make up the difference until you reach minimum wage. (On a different note, if a customer does a dine-and-dash on you, your employer is not permitted to garnish your wages to make up for the cost of the meal.)

Tips should be given for good service-- exceeding minimum expectations. This attitude/expectation of deserving an extra tip just because you did your job...no. 15% for someone doing the minimum effort and has to be actively flagged down to get a refill on my water? Say hello to a 10% tip instead. I've even worked for tips before (ice cream store), and yes, they were nice when people were generous, but I also never felt like I deserved one for something so easy as serving a single cup of ice cream with no mix-ins.

Also, I could have sworn that 10% used to be norm for tipping before it was 15%-20%. Did I imagine that?
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Mitch, "If you fail to give the person who serves you the expected tip you are tricking them into serving you for free and cheating them, plain and simple."

No, they're doing the job they were hired to do and are expected to perform (and to perform well). And what about when they do that job exceedingly poorly? Should I still pay them because gosh darn it, at least they showed up to work, I guess? The tip is a bonus to be earned.

As for fair... well, why should the server get paid less by me because I only ordered a $10 salad while you were ordering a $30 steak? Same amount of effort and service on their part, but radically different tips. It's just a stupid system. (For the record, yes, I DO tip. I don't think I've ever not tipped anyone, and I'll even tip on take-out if I like the place/people. It's still kind of a stupid system that's been overly integrated into service transactions, and I disagree with how it's been elevated to a required obligation regardless of actual performance, at least to some people.)
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
@MadMolecule "A restaurant server has opportunities to screw with your food--your food--that a fast-food employee could only dream of. The hope of a decent tip at the end of the night is what keeps him/her from doing that..."

So this is your "honor system"? There is no honor system in a situation where doing the "honorable" thing is just a preventative measure. What you describe is at best a bribe system, and at worst an extortion system.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I live in the UK. I get good service when I eat out anyway. The staff know they will get whatever rate they get according to the pay scale they are on. If people get bad service the manager gets a complaint and the member of staff is brought up sharply.

IE the same as every other industry...why should restuarants be any different to, say, buying a PC? It would be ludicrous to tip people in my local Tesco's for showing me where the cinnamon bagels are..thats their job.

Likewise, workers in the service industry know they provide a service and will be reprimanded if they dont.

Tipping is basically a good way for people managing food establishments to get out of paying their workers a decent wage and leaving the onus on to the guests who shouldnt have to be responsible for the welfare of the workers there.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Tempscare, the tip is not a bonus or a gift. It is the equivalent of a wage for workers who earn less than minimum wage because the customers are expected to pay at least 15% of the bill for service. I will pay the minumum 15% if the service isn't great, because I have class, but I would never stiff a server. I even went back to a restaurant the next day to leave money for the waiter because I made a mistake doing the math in my head when I figured out the tip.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
@Ben Eshbach: "There is no honor system in a situation where doing the 'honorable' thing is just a preventative measure."

True enough, and to be honest, when I'm leaving a tip I don't think of it as a "thank-you" to the server for not poisoning my cheeseburger. I personally think of tipping as a way to generate and spread goodwill, and to let the server know I appreciate the job they do. I also know what a server's actual wages look like, and I'm aware that if no one left voluntary tips, restaurants would have to raise wages, and their food would get more expensive and the service would get worse. Tipping is a collective benefit to society, but rarely a personal one to the tipper (unless the server remembers you next time you're in there).

However: After reading a bunch of the mean-spirited comments in this thread, it seemed that a "what's in it for me" explanation might be a litle more comprehensible to some of the previous posters.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
I doubt that this will be read now that it's dropped off the end of the front page, but it does seem that the last couple of commenters are missing the point somewhat.
Mitch - a tip is exactly a 'bonus or gift'. I just looked at the wiki page for 'tip' and it defines it as a voluntary extra payment.
When it comes to the US, I will happily concede that it's the custom to pay it, and when I finally get the chance to go back there I fully expect & intend to have to familiarise myself with how tipping works over on that side of the pond. However, that doesn't change the more general principle that tipping should not be considered an automatic - that negates the whole purpose of a tip. It's the employers job to pay their staff - if that means that prices go up, so be it - the staff are better looked after and I can happily expect service to be better, since the staff won't be able to just assume they'll get their tip.
Abusive comment hidden. (Show it anyway.)
Login to comment.
Click here to access all of this post's 40 comments
Email This Post to a Friend
"Tipping Properly in Every Food Scenario"

Separate multiple emails with a comma. Limit 5.

 

Success! Your email has been sent!

close window
X

This website uses cookies.

This website uses cookies to improve user experience. By using this website you consent to all cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

I agree
 
Learn More