The most talked about location of Kidd’s treasure is up the Connecticut River somewhere on Clarke’s Island. Rumor has it that the gold has to dug up by three people, in complete silence, during a full moon with the moon directly overhead. There’s a legend that three men once followed all these directions to the very end. But once the treasure chest started to be uncovered, one of the yelled “You’ve hit it”. Upon hearing a direct violation of the rules, the chest promptly sank into the sand and out of reach.
From the Upcoming ueue, submitted by sish2000.
"One of them" would be better.
How about "five buried treasures that are still buried"?